The Optimistic March of a Lifelong Knicks Fan

Sure, the Knicks are brutal right now, but there are still reasons to stay optimistic

via Fox Sports

It’s been a turbulent season for the Knicks, as we have come to expect as the lucky fans of the team.

The ride is never smooth.

While expectations are always high and greatness is almost always desired, it seems to be constantly out of reach. They currently sit at 25–37, good (bad?) for 13th place in the Eastern Conference. Their abysmal February tanked their season.

A 2–9 record caused them to plummet down the standings, and they are arguably at their lowest point this season, one would hope. The playoff race is over for them, Kurt “My Career Coaching Record is Unimaginably Bad” Rambis is taking up residence on the bench, and there was an audible chant of “Let’s Go Heat” at a recent home game.

Times have been better in New York.

BUT! Last year, this team won 17 games. They’ve already cleared that figure with a month and a half left on the schedule. Some truly exhilarating moments have gone down this year, and they’ve played some games that have given the fanbase reason to celebrate (@ Oklahoma City and @ Toronto in November? vs. Boston in January?).

Overall, the team was tolerable to watch for the first half of the year, and even reached levels of FUN for a hot second there. It hasn’t all been roses, especially lately, but it hasn’t been as excruciating as last year was.

So the question is, how are we supposed to feel about this season?

It’s an interesting question. On one hand, there have been plenty positive signs. Kristaps Porzingis stands as the most obvious one. His presence will remain a bright spot on this team for years to come. Carmelo Anthony has been RELATIVELY healthy. After a rough start, Robin Lopez has come into his own and played incredibly well. The team seemed to genuinely enjoy playing with one another earlier on.

On the other hand, the negatives have become more evident as the year has progressed. The coaching conundrum that looms over the team isn’t going to go away anytime soon. Weak play from the backcourt has been detrimental, and as a result, opposing guards mutilate the Knicks on a nightly basis. The rotations are still a mess. And Sasha Vujacic still calls New York home.

So, how do those positives and negatives compare when evaluating the season as a whole? It’s a balance that we have to gauge in sports and life all the time. Sports are entertainment in its purest form, a spectacle that people are meant to enjoy and revel in.

We as a people obsess over sports and the athletes that hold the spotlight. Some of us live and die with our teams. Unfortunately, we have died a tragic death with the Knicks lately. Should that be our feeling for the season as a whole? Or is the recent stink surrounding the team shrouding the steps forward that the team has made? Ultimately, it’s up to you. All any of us really want is one thing: A team that plays the game of basketball that we can enjoy and experience success with.


Let’s start at the beginning —

The Knicks inked plenty of useful players to reasonable contracts during the summer, giving the team an identity after a disgrace of a 2014–15 season. Arron Afflalo and Robin Lopez were brought in to defend and play important roles on the team right away, while guys like Derrick Williams, Kyle O’Quinn, and Kevin Seraphin were brought in to provide much needed depth.

Kristaps Porzingis and Jerian Grant were drafted as projects that would hopefully develop into strong NBA players with time. The return of role players Lance Thomas and Jose Calderon would bolster the rotations, while the return of Carmelo Anthony would be an absolute blessing. Their offseason was viewed as a step forward, and fans were generally pleased with the moves that Phil made.

The season began, and surprisingly, Porzingis was ahead of schedule. He emerged as the Knicks’ second best player almost immediately, and the guy that was supposed to be a season away from being a season away had arrived to lead the caravan earlier than expected. The buzz around the team was palpable. Kristaps was getting national attention and the Knicks were vying for a playoff spot while consistently hovering around .500. Times were good and fans were happy. The Knicks were abandoning their old ways of rash decision making and buffoonery.

Then, in a flurry, the team lost steam. Derek Fisher was fired for (snogging Matt Barnes’ ex-wife) the perceived lack of experience he possessed, the bench stopped producing, and play from veterans fell off. They lost 15 of 18. Suddenly, it wasn’t fun anymore. It didn’t feel like a step forward; it felt the same old Knicks.

After the February swoon —

Fans are justifiably upset. I’m upset. We’re all upset! No one likes to have a team with plenty of games left on the docket be out of the playoff race. It takes a certain magic away from the games. Knowing that the wins don’t matter anymore aside from small moral victories is a little sickening. The Knicks don’t possess a draft pick this year, so no rooting interest can stem from that (Thanks, Andrea!).

Once the season becomes a trudge to the end, the temperature of the team is taken. We became accustomed to moves like the Bargnani trade that we had to talk ourselves into liking. That was the only way to keep ourselves sane.

“Yeah, Bargnani can’t rebound or play defense, but at least he’s a model of health! And he can stretch the floor!!… Hold up, you’re telling me he hasn’t played a full season in three years? And can’t shoot threes anymore? Nah, he’ll be fine.”

The moves that they made seemed to blow up in their face, and the moves they didn’t make have looked bad in hindsight (Sup, Kyle Lowry?). That’s what made the beginning of this season so exciting. We finally had an executive in Phil Jackson that would preserve the team’s assets while making shrewd moves to improve the team during the offseason.

And, by in large, he did just that! The Knicks didn’t make any dumb trades or dole out any bad contracts. The frustration that fans feel for this year’s squad is not all because of this year, though. It has been built up over the years. The lack of trust and enjoyment that fans have had for this team has festered from within the fanbase the better part of a decade. I, like many Knicks fans my age, grew up being a fan of a team that was consistently a punch line; a footnote on the backside of NBA greatness.


via ESPN

When I was in elementary school, I would flip the Knicks on with my dad sometimes. My dad was a huge Knicks fan growing up, and raised me the same way. But, during this time period their general terribleness and his role of a father of four depressed his fandom a bit. When we would turn a game on, the info panel for DirecTV would block the score initially, and would take a few seconds to remove itself from the screen. It felt like every time that info panel cleared, disappointment set in. “Nuggets 83, Knicks 67.” “Bulls 99, Knicks 82.” “Mavericks 128, Knicks 78.” Losing was an expectation.

Once I grew up enough to commit myself to the team, I sold my soul. Starting around the 2009 season, I did my best to watch every game. The 2012–13 season was the most fun I’ve ever had watching a team play, and that’s coming from a huge Giants, Yankees, and Rangers fan. All of those team have had their share of success in recent years.

There’s something about basketball, though.

As Clyde would say, it’s like sweet jazz, full of improvisation and beauty. Over the years, I have spread my love of this irritating franchise to plenty. During that season, my friends and I would get together for every Friday night game.

When my girlfriend at the time and I would hang out, if the Knicks played, we watched. I didn’t miss a single game. When they lost, my mood was affected. I would be upset.

After the loss to the Pacers in the playoffs, I hugged my poor cat for 10 minutes because I was so upset. Have I mentioned that they were only a 54 win team? Coming off of a first round exit the season before? That they weren’t viewed as legitimate contenders by many because of LeBron and the Heat? This is how badly I wanted this team to be good. A small taste of greatness propelled my expectations through the roof, and the loss pummeled me right back through the floor.


“Why are you saying all of this? Why is this relevant? Do you just want to go on a tangent to force us to hear about your life, Matt?!?!? You selfish bastard!!”

Okay, simmer down, quintessential Knicks fan full of pent-up aggression! I’m saying this because I think any fan of the Knicks can relate to my experiences. All we want from this team is respectability. Look at how happy the fanbase was when the team showed signs of life at the beginning of this season.

It’s not like the team was lighting the world on fire by any means. The best record in terms of winning percentage that they possessed during this entire season was 8–6. We desperately want this team to win. It’s not a necessity, but is sure as hell makes us happier as human beings.

Honestly, when it comes down to it, it’s just sports. I have had my friends and family say to me on more than one occasion, “Why do you care so much?” I have my reasons, many of which extend beyond the sport itself. The moments that sports can provide us are like nothing else in life. Despite this, unfortunately, the industry is inherently disappointing to its followers. Your team can’t win the championship every year, and if you’re a Knicks fan, you sit back and wonder if your team will ever win a championship during your lifetime. Tough sledding is all part of expectations as a fan.

The sport itself is not the end all, be all, however. It’s what the sport can make us FEEL. Jubilation when Kristaps slams the ball through the hoop off of a missed shot. High-fiving your friends when Melo pulls off a classic jab-step jump shot. Replaying the high points of the game in your head when the buzzer sounds. This is what we crave. The small moments that contribute to the overall success of our favorite sports team in the world.

The Knicks may not be at their best right now, but their outlook is more positive than it has been in some time. They have a budding star that has already taken New York by storm, along with some cap space to play with in the coming years. The free agents that will be hitting the market in the coming summers are insanely talented (especially at the guard position), and each one represents an opportunity for the team to improve. I’ve lost some faith in the “New York pull” for free agents, but I’m not counting out a huge splash just yet.

It’s not fun to be a Knicks fan right now. Nevertheless, let’s have some perspective. We knew after last year that it was going to be a while until the team could get back to being a contender again. They hit the jackpot with Porzingis, which is the first major step that needed to be taken. Imagine if he ended up struggling! (Actually, scratch that, a world without Kristaps is not a world I want to call home, in reality or in fiction). The road ahead is foggy, and the Knicks could have more roster turnover after the season, as plenty of contributors are coming off the books.

I hate clichés, and I hate preaching, but patience really can be a virtue sometimes. This version of the Knicks was never going to win a title, or even contend for one. The fact that fans are so upset shows just how badly each and every person wants greatness for this team.

That greatness could be on the horizon. That horizon could be within reach, or it could be many moons away. They could strike out on every free agent available. Porzingis could, god forbid, not continue to improve at a consistent rate.

But, when the success comes, it’s going to be sweet.

When the small moments that have been experienced by fans start to string together into long, positive memories of a season, it’s worth it. Because in the end, sports are more than they appear at the surface. As a fan, they can build us up and form who we are.

You may have read all of this and disagreed with everything, think I’m a sap, an optimistic jabroni. That’s fine. I don’t want to give the appearance that I am absolving the team of any wrongdoing this year. I went to the game on Friday against the Magic, and just 30 seconds in, fans around me were already rolling their eyes because I was yelling at the Knicks. I’m as frustrated with the team as anyone. But, take a moment to put aside your frustration and recognize the reality of the situation: Ultimate success was never meant to be achieved this year. If we as a fanbase lose our optimism for the future, we have nothing to look forward to. And as long as the positives of this season roll into next season, some good has the potential of coming our way. Have faith.

Or, I could come to realization that I’m a Knicks fans and therefore banished to utter and complete despair until the end of time.

Either or.